degenerator
3 years ago
Cool topic, though I agree with you on the notion that Evangelion is quite derivative, something that is quite obvious if you've seen some anime, and no doubt very intnentional. I do find your points of comparison... odd? I'm not going after your opinion on Rahxephon or Nadesico being better, that's a fair opinion
degenerator
3 years ago
(although i fail to see how Nadesico is all that simmilar beyond being the "deconstruction" of mecha tropes people wrongfully ascribe to NGE). What made me scratch my head are the other comparisons like Votoms, which I really fail to see a sensible comparison to (I find Votom’s themes on fatalism and free will a lot more interesting then it’s focus on war).
degenerator
3 years ago
If you’re making the effort to point out simmilarities I would much rather direct my attention to Go Nagai’s work which is pretty overtly referenced in the show, as well as other Yoshiyuki Tomino anime (that aren’t Dunbine) like Gundam and Ideon, anime that Anno himself have admitted influenced NGE greatly, hell you have a tokusatsu page on your site right? Ultraman can be very relevant here.
degenerator
3 years ago
Secondly one could also note a link to Macross, though not something I personally see all that well in the work itself Anno did work on DYRL so that might be noteworthy perhaps? Not at all trying to be critical, but I felt I should point it out. Cheers
pagespages
3 years ago
These are all good points, noted. Gundam, Ideon and Ultraman are definitely going to be talked about (maybe Tekkaman Blade too).
pnnamerica
3 years ago
B-b-b-b-but itachi and sauske, the ninja war. Eye powers. How could you say such a thing?
pagespages
3 years ago
P.S: The Web Novel (which I know is running behind), will have its first major release in October.
chipsfunfun
3 years ago
get ready for me to absolutely make fanart of your characters and have crushes on some
letslearntogether
3 years ago
It is cute! It makes me think of 80's style manga strips like Don't Cry, Tanaka-kun by Hiroshi Tanaka or Chiisana Koi no Monogatari by Chikako Mitsuhashi.
sakana
3 years ago
Nah it slaps. When I was younger I didn't understand the appeal of it, now that I'm older I have a real appreciation for designs that are a) extremely distinctive (nothing else looks quite like CSC and you can spot it a mile away) and b) expressive while being simple.
noxu
3 years ago
It's a good art style. Especially for such a long running and commercially successful series
pnnamerica
3 years ago
Do: Use deodorant and take showers. Great list all around though, jokes aside.
pagespages
3 years ago
Yeah, I know, I want to see others opinions though and also I plan on expanding outreach to all ten active users.
Thanks! I really like your guide for otakus lmao