Neocities allows anyone to create a free web site to express themselves. Want to create your own awesome site? Join us!
eastathenaeum
1 year ago
Looking at your properties of limits list, I never understood why they never just say that the function of limits commutes/distributes. It is after all knocked around as if it were an algebraic function.
xpaper
1 year ago
Currently the only rigorous notion of 4-dimensionality I feel I understand well is the Linear Algebra notion of a vector space with 4 linearly independent vectors. Everytime I try looking into tensors, I just get confused, so I'd be interested in seeing what you mean by "a metric tensor with a negative eigenvalue." I know what a metric and an eigenvalue is, at least.
eastathenaeum
1 year ago
After seeing enough of these, visualizing in enough different ways, and thinking about it for too long, 4D space becomes so easy to understand that it's kind of a no-brainer. Not going to lie though, it took me years.
eastathenaeum
1 year ago
The negative eigenvalue in time has everything to do with entropy in a positive direction, especially in particle interactions. Spacetime is dynamic, which means that it is tending eventually to a point of rest. This played a large role alongside the universe's expansion leading to the assumption of heat death, that time itself would eventually breakdown, no events, even though space would continue to expand forever.
eastathenaeum
1 year ago
Don't beat me up if I got any of that wrong, by the way. There's been loads of observations in the last few years alone, especially with JWST, that have been telling us that our existing cosmological models are definitely fundamentally flawed and in need of rewriting.
xpaper
1 year ago
To be honest I wouldn't know if you are right or wrong lol physics is by no means my area of expertise. I was hoping for more of a pure-math explanation. For me 4D or 5D or nD vector spaces already make sense (just add another coordinate), even if I don't know what they look like.
eastathenaeum
1 year ago
As far as purely mathematical, I don't know of any applications. I was trying to say in the intro while angrily shaking my fist that time has nothing to do with it. There's always one that's like "Time is the fourth!" All of these softwares are pure Euclidian space, because responsible adults made them. Lol
letslearntogether
1 year ago
@xpaper - It sounds like you already got the gist of it. Most of this software seems to treat the concept of "four dimensions" as simply an extra coordinate, let's call it w. Changing that w coordinate gives us another space, while changing x, y, or z changes our place within that particular space.
letslearntogether
1 year ago
In the context of Physics, a "scalar" is only a magnitude (e.g.: a speed given in miles per hour). A "vector" is a magnitude with direction (e.g.: 60MPH due North). Both are "tensors". A scalar is a "tensor of rank-0", a vector is a "tensor of rank-1", and so on.
letslearntogether
1 year ago
More specifically, tensors are objects that can be described as points on a "manifold". A manifold is a space that may have different "local" and "global" properties. A common example is the Earth. Locally, its surface seems like a flat plane, but globally, it is a sphere. This is a concept from Topology.
letslearntogether
1 year ago
The concept of tensors is not used as much when it comes to Linear Algebra. A rank-2 tensor can be described by a matrix, but tensors are not synonymous with matrices. In Physics, you might switch from using one branch of math to the other depending on what you are describing though. So, the term "four dimensions" is often referring to either one of two concepts when used in Physics:
letslearntogether
1 year ago
1. The use of four coordinates where x, y, z describe where something is in regular Euclidean space, and a coordinate t that describes when it is there. Simple and intuitive. But when dealing with extremes of speed, like in the case of Relativity Theory, we would use "Minkowski spacetime".
letslearntogether
1 year ago
2. In Minkowski spacetime, we still have the three axes of Euclidean space, but "time" is considered a fourth axis that objects travel along at the speed of light. This makes the speed of light constant for every observer and everything else is measured relative to that.
letslearntogether
1 year ago
Personally, I feel that a lot of seemingly complex math has been thrown at what are essentially simple relationships, so I understand eastathenaeum's displeasure with how the idea of "four dimensions" is often presented.
xpaper
1 year ago
I have varying levels of familiarity with everything mentioned here. However, I feel like I still don't have an answer to the question of how someone would go about determining eigenvalues for the "metric tensor of a dimension" and what those objects are in a mathematically rigorous sense. But when I look into it that's precisely the part that remains mystifying.
eastathenaeum
1 year ago
It sounds like the confusion lies in assuming that spacetime is an object residing within dimensions as opposed to the dimensions being a part of spacetime itself. Basically the metric tensors are functions that translate how space looks to us with what is actually going on and visa versa, a feature of projection for mapping in differential geometry.
eastathenaeum
1 year ago
I'm thinking about either changing or removing the wording now, because on all levels, peoples' minds are already made up for whether or not time exists. To me that's kind of a dumb argument, because how do you experience something for yourself and claim it doesn't exist? It's like saying emotions don't exist because they are just biological chemical reactions, when in reality that's an argument for how they exist.
letslearntogether
1 year ago
@eastathenaeum - As in teach professionally? You are too kind. No, I just love learning and sharing...While I cannot speak for xpaper, I think they were trying to grasp what "the negative eigenvalue of a metric tensor" means mathematically. In other words, how do we calculate that? Are we treating a metric tensor as a matrix and then finding its eigenvalue?
letslearntogether
1 year ago
If I had to take a guess, from your descriptions on the dynamic nature of spacetime, I have a feeling that you are using the inverse of the resultant eigenvector(s) to define "time"...as if spacetime itself is expanding at the speed of light, something like Einstein's cosmological constant...
letslearntogether
1 year ago
Don't quote me on that though. I could be entirely wrong. I'm just trying to understand exactly how you are looking at the situation. You obviously have a deep understanding of it.
letslearntogether
1 year ago
@xpaper - The concept of spacetime is such an interesting amalgam of Differential Geometry, Topology, and Linear Algebra that it can be a challenge to understand it. Some of the best videos to get a general idea of the Math behind it that I have seen are: https://m.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL__fY7tXwodmfntSAAyBDxZ4_eE3ZwbFE
letslearntogether
1 year ago
I usually approach the idea of "dimension" in terms of how many coordinates are needed to specify any location within a given space. So, a "1-dimensional line" only needs one coordinate to specify any point along it, a "2-dimensional plane" needs two coordinates to specify any location within it, and so on.
letslearntogether
1 year ago
In the same way that we might think of a "2-dimensional square" as a slice of a "3-dimensonal cube", we might think of a 3D cube as a slice of a "4-dimensional hypercube". People might trip over visualizing such a thing, but again, all we are really thinking about is how many coordinates. When it comes to applying this idea to Physics, well...
letslearntogether
1 year ago
To be honest, I think Einstein (and the theoretical physicists who followed him) go a little overboard with the Math sometimes, to the point of obscuring the actual physical phenomenon that they are describing...though I am not as harsh with my assessment of Relativity as Nikola Tesla. 😂
letslearntogether
1 year ago
One has to keep in mind that Einstein formulated his idea of spacetime when scientists were arguing over the constitution of the aether. So, I think Einstein was like, "Here guys, let's just use this mathematical model to describe light and gravity for now. We'll figure out the composition of the aether later." Unfortunately, it seems to have led to a lot of confusion.
eastathenaeum
1 year ago
No, my understanding sucks, but thank you for the vote of confidence. I've only taken physics for engineering & science majors 1 & 2 in college as well as some others completely unrelated to cosmology. I've read about it a lot in Wikipedia over the decades and kept up with hypothetical models trying to make breakthroughs, but that hardly constitutes as studying.
eastathenaeum
1 year ago
The eigenvalue is determined from a metric tensor matrix, which is the scalar equivalent to the eigenvector, so yes, that is correct. I'm kind of falling down a rabbit hole trying to find pure mathematical context, and everything I'm looking up leads back to physical interpretation. In relativity, negative eigenvalues are pretty much a given rather than a consequence. I never gave it any thought.
eastathenaeum
1 year ago
I just called a friend over this after numerous carefully worded searches. He has two degrees, one in math, and he told me there is no purely mathematical context, that all it would do is flip the field and that it is never used. Now my brain hurts because this doesn't sound at all like the context laid out in relativity. Lol
art music videogames programming anime games food personal writing cats blog movies books gaming fashion photography comics design animation horror game drawing coding manga arte portfolio furry reading poetry ocs technology cute kpop musica history education animals programacion film fun roblox literature sports philosophy html nature science programing tech videogame travel politics minecraft web gamedev retro school videojuegos life youtube computers cartoons love pokemon 2000s blogging diary video illustration fantasy pink dogs random comic idk gardening internet memes videos oc linux ai test cooking y2k queer kawaii webcomic nostalgia tv fandom arg aesthetic journal emo business news worldbuilding fanfiction cars crafts vocaloid learning health media films silly stuff space math fiction 90s website cutecore stories culture scifi etc arts cat painting football css graphics journaling homestuck baking marketing goth software punk lgbt 3d crochet commissions sanrio cinema sport pixelart archive psychology artist digitalart program dance me diy comida shows makeup dnd series characters trans funny metal religion lgbtq graphicdesign lifestyle creativity cool editing fanart aboutme entertainment clothes streaming sonic rpg indie friends javascript development code scene webcomics story plants roleplay comedy guitar languages rock weird webcore everything electronics zines ttrpg sewing study community hacking gay aesthetics reviews engineering cyberpunk webdesign educacion beauty basketball fnaf computer informatica it originalcharacters soccer weirdcore social vintage oldweb vtuber spirituality discord photos pets project deltarune blogs vaporwave architecture shop storytelling flowers movie information coffee clothing about thoughts language shopping undertale japan hobbies biology nintendo testing mlp cosplay magic html5 book creative lore fitness crypto digital money radio ttrpgs nothing experimental blinkies fandoms chat physics info alternative tecnologia astronomy cybersecurity websites site singing juegos japanese furries bugs birds occult autism wip witchcraft anything other finance research band resume futbol tvshows theatre crafting profile television sleep lain sleeping dolls projects gamedevelopment moda personalwebsite events work vr system linguistics genshin apps interests vampires photo all knitting fish ghchs yaoi dreams splatoon transgender python webdevelopment free meme astrology gatos carrd rap fanfic puzzle mentalhealth toys developer aliens wiki collecting windows coquette app poems romance dancing pixels drawings animations visualnovels fortnite robots cartoon bio touhou english dog deportes family tarot frutigeraero gothic stamps intro a marvel skateboarding animes medicine pizza online modding security essays links mathematics humor data gamedesign hiking characterdesign gym osc interactive fnf adventure teaching journalism gyaru mystery no gallery dragons chess roleplaying lol fansite creepypasta hobby rp zine zonelets objectshows jfashion gifs birthday popculture puzzles pixel twitch resources yuri mythology home vkei meow law myself musicals breakcore ffxiv ocean dreamcore novels traveling scenecore tf2 noise blender piano hiphop introduction audio privacy peliculas death recipes graphic libros danganronpa progamming jogos stars dark style twine pjsk rpgs podcast bfdi ecommerce indiegames hellokitty plushies swag communism shrine android studying socialmedia robotics paranormal car production pictures activism omori awesome spanish wrestling bunnies running foods none pinterest utau christianity boardgames jewelry lolita lesbian amor deporte educational anarchism electronic student vent things craft filmmaking girls travelling volleyball misc unblocked feminism god grunge cine scratch sharks store bitcoin mario geography clowns songs dev webdev maths computing designing old realestate 80s outdoors jpop 3dmodeling blue doom pc transformers bl vtubers help environment flash dinosaurs images collage brasil college starwars stickers java tools jazz tumblr fotografia creepy bts acting novel chemistry cafe jesus epic event services alt baseball trains computerscience mcr construction yoga escuela tea translation plurality pastel lego warriorcats cyber args programar collection retrogaming theater persona southpark manhwa whatever multimedia yes therian programas videoediting js tcc cozy pop vlog monsters programmer weed tabletop horses gamer trading podcasts truecrime historia supernatural forum f1 techno medical otherkin shoes miku literatura tiktok people skating hardware videography dc weather draw estudiante bsd insects drama cricket skincare girly economics angels socialism salud enstars homepage lgbtqia green ecology opensource maps dj search restaurant freedom whimsy learn modeling hi surrealism swimming kirby ropa turismo kandi sound curso digitalmarketing animales kidcore ideas nerd trinkets text animanga vhs artwork bible world closedspecies tattoos kdrama conspiracy petz halloween filmes cleaning tourism author depression edm chatting cultura service analysis shitposting hockey furniture healthcare 3dprinting fishing racing cv sociology academia did egl videogaming surreal drugs friendship hardcore brazil blockchain rats bands homework tennis women frogs hair scary knowledge sculpture chill eating wedding mobile programa general sketching colors plural networking library visualnovel sciencefiction academic thrifting artes livros christian cryptocurrency ambient soft informacion creation aviation quotes alterhuman analog rpgmaker genshinimpact programacao purple server tutorials anarchy society gacha mods truth university practice species estudio mangas foss graffiti sites retrogames water ux glitch writting cryptids ghosts wellness anthropology company batman sustainability bot erotica miriadax programs jjba forsaken cycling onepiece review conlang medieval magazine garden character harrypotter css3 writer neocities schoolproject live guns google webseries class esoteric noticias nails yapping superheroes tattoo kids otaku theology theory archives 3dart twitter rants camping talking bikes revival ceramics cs instagram cards startrek building animal crime vampire performance shitpost disney unblockedgames analoghorror rhythmgames notes crocheting play blood illustrations future advertising church lostmedia idols dating decor french os articles evangelion industrial musicproduction viajes house liminal apple training handmade shrines meditation spiderman synthesizers originalcharacter creating ultrakill concerts chaos interactivefiction kdramas frontend shoegaze selfship youtuber voiceacting content desing jobs party scrapbooking communication prompts sims seals folklore designer crk vlogs disability satire new exercise visualkei neopets tareas terror datascience silliness spooky embroidery calculator finalfantasy entretenimiento tecnology repair vrchat tarea zelda mylittlepony animalcrossing doodles quiz paganism magick rambling facts halflife shifting vinyl sweets sanat poesia rainbow geek creatures joke cult vida something marxism commission black overwatch developing download hack spiritual vtubing musics anthro cheese animating jokes miscellaneous photoshop desarrollo hotel adhd daily kink islam bass creativewriting ranfren tic webring mtg beach club conlangs vegan scp songwriting military happy christmas private fanfics arcane php projectsekai ar zombies self doctorwho agriculture underground tokipona trabajo mha productivity todo mecha ia yugioh more drinks oldroblox shoujo tamagotchi tips cottagecore archival edits 1 pet tokusatsu studies map glitter secret gender motorcycles generator collections ciencia musician mushrooms ui red rave beginner oldinternet dandysworld vibes cities randomstuff programm lofi dungeonsanddragons faith videgames hosting words gossip lolitafashion cake stupid
Thank you, I was actually taking notes on a Topology article from Quanta Magazine a few weeks ago - I intend to make a full-depth Topology page after Multivariable and Differential Equations have been completely fleshed out.